Lead Generation vs. Affiliate Marketing: What is Better?

Lead Generation vs Affiliate Marketing What is Better

Lead generation vs. affiliate marketing: if you are searching for new ways to make money off your website, you probably heard of lead generation and affiliate marketing. Are they the same thing?

Table of contents

If you have not heard of these terms, here is a brief description:

Both methods of monetizing your website can be super-profitable

But, which one is better, lead generation or affiliate marketing? 

Lead Generation vs Affiliate Marketing What is Better

The answer is: depends on the kind of business niche you are in. 

Lead generation and affiliate marketing are simply two distinctive tools in your arsenal, and each has its strengths and weaknesses.

Helpful Resource – Learn About Lead Generation: The Ultimate How-to guide.

Lead Generation: Pros and Cons

A lead generation is a tool that may or may not be effective in your particular industry. Be aware of lead generation’s following strengths and weaknesses as you consider when monetizing your traffic.

Lead Generation Pros:

how to make passive income online

#1 – Lead generation can be more profitable compared to affiliate marketing

Some business niches where a lead rate is higher than what you would potentially earn from a commission on a sale. Here are the industries that are known to be lucrative for lead generation:

  • Insurance – whether it is for auto, home, life, health, or even a small business, the insurance industry thrives on generating qualified leads. Since the insurance market is such a profitable financial niche, many businesses are willing to pay top dollar for quality (targeted) leads.
  • Home repair & remodeling – Have you ever tried to find a home repair or remodeling contractor? If yes, you’ve probably been pressured into entering your name, address, and type of service you are up for. This information of yours is being monetized by referring you to select contractors who are eager to pay just to contact you and offer their services.
  • Legal services – We all know lawyers charge ludicrous rates for their legal services. Competition is stiff. Law firms of all types and forms are often ready to pay fat fees for potential clients.
  • High education – colleges and universities don’t pay commissions if you refer to students. However, they do pay for qualified leads. With the prices colleges or universities charge for tuition and all the extras that are included (housing, food, books), students are a highly profitable business, and leads in this niche have typically high commission.
  • Credit cards – credit card clients are worth gold since most people aren’t too good at paying off their balance and therefore rack up lots of interest fees.
  • Mortgages are another niche in the financial industry where lots of interest is paid on home loans, which drives up quality leads.
  • Dating – yes, with marriage rates on the decline, the longing for dating services at your fingertips got popular. Dating apps can charge big monthly membership fees, and their potential client base is worth quite a bit.
  • Senior & Assisted Care – with an aging population comes greater and greater need for expensive daily care. This niche is geographic focused, so consider that.
  • Local Medical Services – everything from dentists, chiropractors, massage therapists to other local medical-like service providers often pay well for qualified leads they will repeatedly convert afterward.

You may also want to read:

#2 – Lead generation is better for industries where paying a commission to violate the laws

Paying a commission is illegal in the United States when government money is involved and possibly in other highly regulated industries by either the federal governments or state governments. On the other hand, lead generation is a legal method of paying for potential clients.

#3 – Customers don’t need to spend their money for you to get paid

Purchasing something is often the final step to manage in the transaction process but often the most difficult. With we are talking about lead generation, you don’t have to overcome this hurdle to get your commission. Typically you only need that potential customer to provide their information, which is less of a risk than actually paying.

#4 – Many tools are available to help you capture leads easily

Technology has advanced to the point where you can use simple lead gen software like OptinMonster or a more fully-featured customer relationship management (CRM) platform like Pipedrive to capture leads.

OptinMonster lets you design several forms or offer templates to use on your website, such as embedding in pages or delivering pop-ups based on visitors’ user behavior in order to convert all of your traffic into leads.

Many of these tools allow you to target pop-ups and lead generation forms to various visitors based on their demographics. 

For example, suppose you are working on generating leads to a particular market (like for lawyers in Manhattan). In that case, you can make use of the geo-location targeting feature to only offer legal offers to visitors from Manhattan. This feature allows you to do a much better job at qualifying and segmenting leads before you get to capture them.

#5 – If you sell leads directly, you can negotiate rates

In lead generation, you can either sell leads directly to the company seeking the customer or sell it off to a lead aggregator who then sells them to the end-buyer or buyers. Selling to a lead aggregator can be easier to manage, but you earn less per lead.

Lead Generation vs. Affiliate Marketing

If you maintain relationships with the end-buyer, you can normally negotiate better rates per lead. If you do a good job of fitting your leads according to your buyer’s needs, you will have an advantage.

In some business spheres, it is common practice to sell 1 lead to many end-buyers. This can further maximize your earnings per lead.

Cons of lead generation:

Lead Generation vs Affiliate Marketing What is Better

#6 – Some niches don’t have clients who are willing to buy leads

Leads aren’t invariably worth the time or money to obtain in some industries and may not be an opportunity. For example, Amazon won’t pay for a lead for somebody who could buy a set of computer gadgets. On the other hand, they may reward you for someone who signs up for their free trial on an Audible subscription program.

#7 – Leads need to be qualified for you to get paid

Just because a random person filled out a form does not automatically mean a company will pay you for it. The lead first must be qualified, meaning it has to meet certain standards to be taken as a potential client and worth being “acquired.”

For example, why would a dentist in New York pay for a lead from someone living in London, who has no interest whatsoever in New York’s dental services? They wouldn’t. In this case, such a lead is not “qualified” to be paid for.

To get paid for your leads, you have to think about what potential customers the buyer wants to pay for.

#8 – Stay away from companies that won’t pay for the leads

Years ago, there were problems with companies not actually paying for the leads provided to them. There are a few ways to ensure you do get paid but just be aware that it used to be a problem in the lead generation industry in various companies. It is important to have mechanisms to protect yourself and ensure you are paid for what you deliver.

Affiliate Marketing: Pros and Cons

Lead Generation vs Affiliate Marketing What is Better

Affiliate marketing is a more well-known method for bloggers, influencers, and entrepreneurs, compared to lead generation. In this article, we’ll touch on some of the pros and cons of affiliate marketing so that you’ll get an idea of whether this making money online option will fit within your strategy.

Affiliate Marketing Pros:

Lead Generation vs Affiliate Marketing What is Better

#9 – Affiliate marketing is accessible in a wide spectrum of industries

Affiliate marketing got its start early in popularizing the net around the mid or late ’90s with the advent of link and cookie tracking connected with the rise of e-commerce. As an all-accepted form of online marketing, it has been widely adopted. It is open in a very wide spectrum of markets. Companies that offer products or services of interest to your blog or site’s visitors are the most appealing to you.

#10 – Affiliate marketing is easy to get started with

Generally, all you need to do to get started with affiliate marketing is register, get approved, and start adding affiliate links to your blog. When a visitor clicks on a link and makes a purchase – you receive a commission payment.

What Exactly is Affiliate Marketing Automation?

Of course, there is more to a successful affiliate marketing strategy than that, but the steps to get started are simple. It is really quite easy, so it has become such a mainstream form of monetizing visitors.

#11 – Many affiliate tools help to accurately track referrals 

Affiliate marketing lives and dies by the tracking technology’s effectiveness. Fortunately, the technology is fairly common, which has allowed affiliate programs to increase. 

With the shelf third-party tracking technology, just about any company can offer an affiliate program. Some of the best affiliate programs are offered directly by the companies selling the products or services and not through affiliate networks such as CJ, Rakuten (formerly Linkshare), ShareaSale, or Clickbank. 

You can also use affiliate marketing software, such as Scaleo, to track, monitor, and optimize your traffic in real-time.

#12 – Multiple affiliate options available for competing products or services

The more affiliate programs offered in your industry, the better it is for you to negotiate better terms or have backups if one affiliate program performs badly or is being removed completely. On top of that, you can test different affiliate programs against each other or intensively promote only those that perform better on your website.

Affiliate programs don’t last forever. Many times, companies decide to shut them down completely. If a particular program becomes a large passive income source for you, you need to have a backup plan.

#13 – Affiliate programs can only be promoted based on the terms of service

Affiliate programs rely almost solely on links that set a cookie and/or coupon codes to track a sale to you. If the program’s terms permit, you can promote their affiliate links or coupon everywhere, from your own website or sites to other people’s websites, social media, email, or in third-party apps. This can give you flexibility in ways to market these affiliate products or services and open doors your competitors haven’t taken advantage of yet.

Affiliate Marketing Cons:

Lead Generation vs Affiliate Marketing What is Better

Typically, affiliate programs rely on cookies placed on your web visitors’ PC once they click on your affiliate link. However, if these cookies get blocked or erased, you could lose out on earning a commission if the referrer ends up purchasing.

Some affiliate programs have other tracking methods, like coupons or software, which contains your tracking identifier. 

the future of affiliate marketing after cookies banning

In essence, be aware of the method the affiliate program is using for being tracked. Ask if there are backup methods of tracking in case cookies will be blocked or cleared.

#15 – No ability to negotiate commission rates or terms of service 

Unless you a high-end affiliate, most of the time, commission rates are set fairly low, and cookie duration is short. 

Lead Generation vs. Affiliate Marketing

As an affiliate, you often can’t do much about this unless you send many customers to a company or rival affiliate programs that provide higher commission rates.

Moreover, terms of service can be changed overnight, which can then negatively impact (or cut out completely) your revenue. The cookie duration can decrease, or the commission rate could be lowered. Even worse, the company could decide to only allow affiliates with specific base sales or traffic volume. Take into account this potential volatility and make sure you have multiple revenue sources to compensate in case a particular affiliate program will fall out.

If you enhance your content too heavily with your referral links, it can negatively affect your search ranking. Search engines such as Google consider affiliate links as a form of “advertising” and have strict policies that determine how ad-heavy your content can be to rank high. This is done as a part of their ranking factors.

You will want to be wise in deploying your affiliate links to prevent any Google penalties.

#17 – The customer needs to purchase for an affiliate to get paid

This is the key difference when we compare lead generation vs. affiliate marketing. Getting a visitor to pay for something is a lot harder than getting them to provide their information (lead submission). So, the barrier to getting paid is higher compared to lead generation.

Lead Generation vs Affiliate Marketing What is Better

Another thing to consider is that as the price of a product or service increases, it is difficult to get someone to purchase. You may have to do more work upfront to persuade someone to buy if you are promoting higher priced products.

Each and every affiliate program tells you how long their tracking is set for. This determines how fast your referred visitor has purchased if you get paid.

Lead Generation vs. Affiliate Marketing

For example, suppose a company only has a 24-hour cookie session, and your referred client buys after 30 hours from the time they first clicked on your link. In that case, you will not receive your commission.

Always be cautious of the cookie session duration when you sign up for a particular affiliate program. Some unfriendly affiliate companies know exactly how long it takes someone to purchase from them. So, they set a cookie duration to a shorter timeframe to minimize how much they will pay affiliates for referrals. This isn’t going to make a good long-term business relationship, so stay away from such companies.

Lead Generation vs. Affiliate Marketing: Weaknesses of both

At the start of this article, I said that lead generation and affiliate marketing should be viewed as different tools in your business toolbox. Affiliate marketing isn’t necessarily better than lead generation and vice versa. It is more about using the right tool in the right conditions.

Sometimes, affiliate marketing and lead generation aren’t the right tools at all. Consider, for example, the following drawbacks of both options:

#19 – Sending customers to other companies in exchange for a one-time fee (instead of building your own customer base).

Companies are happy to pay you for a lead or sale commission since they know they will make more money from that customer in the long run compared to what they paid you.

Lead Generation vs Affiliate Marketing What is Better

This is fine if you don’t plan to build your own customer base. Sadly, that isn’t the most strategic decision.

All kinds of benefits open up to you if you grow your own long-term client base. Rather than making fast money off one purchase, what if you decide to build a client base that bought from you repeatedly? 

Sure, suppose you have no plan of marketing insurance or providing home repair services. In that case, you are better off making money from leads. However, if there is an opportunity for you to build your own company, think twice before sending potentially relevant long-term clients to someone else.

#20 – No control over the customer experience

It doesn’t matter if we compare lead generation vs. affiliate marketing or talking in general. When only relying on affiliate marketing and lead generation, you generally cannot control the buying process, the goods or service quality, nor customer support. 

Hence, you are at the mercy of the business. 

This can affect your business not only in terms of lost income but also in terms of a lower trust, depending on how exactly your blog visitors see the association between you and the companies you have partnered with.

When selling your own products or services to your visitors, you have full control over all these aspects. Only you get to decide on the level of quality you produce. You make the buying process painless and reliable. You control how well your clients are taken care of after the purchase through the customer care service.

#21 – Temptation to refer your visitors to companies with a bad reputation

Often, the temptation to increase revenue drives us to make bad choices regarding who we decide to associate ourselves with. 

Sadly, our visitors are the only ones suffering the consequences.

You may also want to read:

When sending visitors to someone else’s company, you would feel better about yourself, knowing you are making good suggestions that serve your visitors’ needs. 

Such products and services don’t necessarily have to have the lowest prices. 

Rarely do the best quality goods cost the lowest price, don’t they?

Your customers have to realize that there is a cost for high quality. 

As long as the pricing structure is transparent and honest, don’t feel inadequate about suggesting higher-cost solutions to your visitors.

Lead Generation vs. Affiliate Marketing – Conclusion

Hopefully, this blog post helped you understand the role of affiliate marketing and lead generation play in your monetization plan. If you were looking to compare lead generation vs. affiliate marketing I think we have touched on all the key points.

Lead Generation vs Affiliate Marketing What is Better

When comparing lead generation vs. affiliate marketing, remember that there is no real difference in terms of method. The essence remains the same – you need to have quality traffic that you then send to a third party website, where the basic information is collected (lead generation), or the visitor makes a purchase (affiliate marketing sale). 

I encourage you to test both affiliate marketing and lead generation to see which one performs better and offers high-quality products and services to your visitors. Good luck!

Related posts
White Label Affiliate Marketing Software - Why It's Important
Elizabeth Sramek
Elizabeth is a Senior Content Manager at Scaleo. Currently enjoying the life in Prague and sharing professional affiliate marketing tips. She's been in the online marketing business since 2006 and gladly shares all her insights and ideas on this blog.
Check out our popular blog posts
Making Money Online
What Are Ads.txt Files and Why You May Need Them?

The transparency bandwagon for programmatic advertising is filling up. Agencies, brands, publishers, vendors, and media buyers are all advocating for a clean-up of the supply chain. So, the awkwardly named …

Elizabeth Sramek
Dec 6, 2021
CPA vs roas
Making Money Online
KPIs in 2022: CPA vs ROAS – Which One is For You?

As a business owner you know, that the two KPIs you are always looking at are: cost per conversion (CPA) and return on ad spend (ROAS). These two metrics allow …

Elizabeth Sramek
Nov 24, 2021
Making Money Online
Factors Which Can Improve Employee Productivity

Spoiler alert: the salary is not enough. It all comes down to employee motivation. It is hard to find a good job, but every employer knows it is even harder …

Elizabeth Sramek
Aug 31, 2021
Making Money Online
Virtual Sales Assistant: Why Do You Need Them?

What is a sales assistant? In the US there are around 3.6 million employed sales assistants, but if you search for this term in Google, you’ll see varying job descriptions: …

Elizabeth Sramek
Aug 27, 2021